Harwin asoiaf reddit

Harwin asoiaf reddit. [2] I've been thinking for a while in the similarities of the stories of Harwin Strong and Princess Rhaenyra, and R+L=J. It still has to line up with the actual story, which is that she fell and hit a rock. Please feel free to comment and contribute. A, without a doubt. After that, strange deaths occur in succession. "It was a trap, milady. This is a place for news and discussions relating to HBO's "Game of Thrones" prequel TV series "House of the Dragon" and George R. AkPakKarvepak. Some are quite intentional. The rumored lover of Princess Rhaenyra Targaryen, Harwin is believed by some to have been the real father of her three sons with her first husband Ser Laenor Velaryon, (Jacaerys, Lucerys, and Joffrey). And unbeknownst to her, her mother and Sandor Clegane are there. It stands upon the very spot where the EXTENDED. Others exist, POVs are mostly canon characters). This subreddit focuses only on the written works and does not allow **any** content from the popular HBO television adaptations of Martin's written work. Like Marwyn, he refers to the majority of Maesters as “gray sheep. Memory inconsistencies are treated as results of "unreliable narrator" rather than errors, as stated in this SSM : Well, not every inconsistency is a mistake, actually. Freakishly tall people seem surprisingly common in ASOIAF, anyone under 6 foot might as well be a hobbit in this world. She will likely be what turns Arya from her scorched earth path of vengeance. Mushroom claims that after being imprisoned in the castle, Daemon began to visit Rhaenyra without However, Harwin is often seen as just Rhaenyra’s glorified sex toy. A lot of people Love her & Daemon, but I think he showed the MAIN. e. Using these dates as a guideline, we can surmise that any children of the Wild Wolf would have to be born between 273 and 283 AC. And after Larys gets beheaded House Strong supposedly dies out in the male line. Published. I'm sure it's been discussed, but Steve Toussaint being The story that the series wants to adapt and tell in the television series is quite big and a lot has to happen in the story, but it already has three episodes and I have the impression that those responsible for the series have no interest in turning Laena, Laenor and Harwin into well-developed characters, that they have no interest in developing them and will just become story devices. “Harwin, it’s me!” For a moment she did not know how to answer. AGOT. Lord Tywin sent his Mountain across the Red Fork with fire and sword, hoping to draw your lord father. What is actually considered "old" in ASOIAF? In reading Fire & Blood again, I was struck by how old Jaehaerys and Alysanne are depicted towards the end of their lives, despite dying at 69 and 64 respectively. Cat heard rumors that Ned had taken Dawn to Ashara after the war, with the possibility that he found his bastard son waiting for him from their earlier hookups. Playing devil's advocate: intermarriage within the targaryan family is the norm, and Rhaenyra is considered basically a woman who is of age to marry and bear children. "Arya Stark, of Winterfell. " "This is the Inn of the Kneeling Man, my lady. Arya's BWB friends and Harwin are there, Hot Pie is there and Gendry, Lady Smallwood is there. By serving an institution greater than oneself, one becomes greater. It does have a strong focus on worldbuilding though (exploration of Essos, OCs from other cultures). Yes, Daemon fought in a duel for Laena’s hand, tried everything to save her life, and mourned her death with News and discussions relating to George R. The last time we saw a guy that genuine about his wife and kids was probably Ned Stark. I don’t think George could have made it made more clear in Fire and Blood. Criston Cole deserves a terrible death. A theory I have heard mentioned, is that Lady Stoneheart hears news of Arya Stark being wed to Ramsay Bolton, and brings the BWB to the North to find her little girl. Only six Winterfell men remained of the twenty her father had sent west with Beric Dondarrion, Harwin told her, and they were scattered. So, even if Harwin were alive, Rhaenyra would marry Daemon without hesitation, which means that she would leave Harwin. The boys are, biologically, Harwin’s. My guess is that Larys Strong caused the fire, possibly with the help of the Hightowers and Criston Cole. No, it's 100% impossible. The fire kills both of them before they can come rushing back to KL. Mero, Strongboar, Lem, Lucas Inchfield, Drogo, Greenbeard, Tytos Blackwood, Moqorro, Victarion, Polliver. So in Fire & Blood, my interpretation had been that Larys was a loyalist to the Green cause as long as Daemon and Rhaenyra lived because they (or at least Daemon) were behind the fire at Harrenhall. Qyburn praises Marwyn; he says that Marywn is one of the few who understood his experiments. The first applies mostly to the book, while the second applies mostly to the show but both could apply to either continuity. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" companion novel, "Fire & Blood. Most fans are probably familiar with the claim that Rhaenyra Targaryen's three eldest sons are actually bastards fathered by Ser Harwin Strong instead of Laenor Velaryon. " One way to avoid that is to make it clear that Rhaenyra’s children were bastards which does provide another rationale for why people would oppose her taking the throne. • 1 yr. Just a thought. and this is my favourite scene out of all the books, so emotional and epic. Create a character and interact with a vast cast of other players! This is the premier roleplay on Reddit, with hundreds of characters and expansive plot lines! News and discussions relating to George R. because it means Rhaenyra's alliance with the Velaryons would be built on lies. No, in that regard it is happening according to the book. After all the hell she went through in ACOK, her finally meeting Harwin just hits differently. Here's a link to my Velaryon family tree. She also doesn't bother comforting Jace or Luke at Laena's funeral about Harwin's death, because she's too caught up in her uncle. To name a few: He accepted her as she was, he would protect her without a second thought, he would have done anything for her & their children, and if she wanted to be with Daemon he would have stood aside for him. This is House of the Dragon related and I'm sorry if this causes a needless argument. Moreover, Rhaenys, Laenor's mother, was the daughter of Jocelyn Baratheon. There’s a ton of shitty relationships in Westeros. There’s no reason to believe thatl even Ser Gregor was able to successfully ambush Beric and Thoros at the Mummers Ford. My thoughts over the years: Watching the season three finale and being so excited for a Lady Stoneheart reveal, then nothing: “Ok, they just had the RW and probably figured that was enough shock for S3, plus season 4 will also be adapted from ASOS, so EXTENDED. Septon Meribald disagreed. ITRP is a Roleplaying game set in the A Song of Ice and Fire Universe by George RR Martin. The points made earlier apply that harwin was the father to rhaenyras kids who had their legitimacy challenged and were also called bastards. “It’s me,” she shouted, “Harwin, it’s me, don’t you know me, don’t you?” The tears came, and she found herself weeping like a baby, just like some stupid little girl. Her first three children are from harwin, but legally from laenor, even though it's very obvious they're from Harwin and not Laenor haha After his and Laenor's death, she marries Daemon and has three more children with him, two boys and a stillborn girl. “More less than more. Otto Hightowers was in league with Lyonel strong and his sons larys and harwin. Harwin went to one knee before her. Jon Arryn lives, so many things are changed, but others are closer to canon (i. I think Rhae's theorized bastard children via Harwin Strong and the associated circumstances in which the show depicted Rhae insisting Otto be removed as hand will make Alicent genuinely think her son deserves to be king. This is a place for news and discussions relating to HBO's "Game of Thrones" prequel TV series… Which is pretty silly. For example literally every time two Valyrian-looking parents have a child, the child has Valyrian looks. The first idea is that Larys = Cheese from the infamous Blood 1. The freakish size of Harwin Strong led him to News and discussions relating to George R. Alicent should never have stayed his hand in the Godswood. The origin of the term is often attributed to his perception as -- just like you noted -- "the Strongest Now that the show has ended, let’s discuss Lady Stoneheart (Spoilers Extended) EXTENDED. He also served as a captain in the City Watch of King's Landing. Rhaenyra's boys looked nothing like Targaryans (similar to Jon). And is also gay and Rhaenyra is gonna jump her one of these days (showverse to clarify). 893K subscribers in the asoiaf community. There are many sorts of Thrones pundits, just as there are many sorts of birds. Daemon doesn't need to kill Harwin to marry rhaenyra so he would be out. Robert was a young Lord from a major family. He still wanted vengence on Harwin for sleeping with Rhaenyra. In the books we don’t really get much to go off of who he is as a person, but somehow he gets with Rhaenyra. And since Lady Stoneheart practically rules the Riverlands, she soon know some Northern girl with a sword is seeking people, especially the BWB! News and discussions relating to George R. In fact, many fans tend to take this claim as fact based on the boys' physical appearances (brown hair, brown eyes, and a Ser Criston’s defection to the Greens is a major blow to Rhaenyra’s cause. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based… Qyburn. r/asoiaf News and discussions relating to George R. The dude who sat with the ladies in 3pusode 3 I forget his name but he becomes the master of whisperers in F&B. 4. 1. Solesky1. Grand Maester Munkun and Septon Eustace call her a bastard of Lord Lyonel Strong, but Mushroom posits she is older, serving as a wetnurse to Lyonel’s sons Harwin and Larys (Breakbones and the Clubfoot), perhaps even to Lyonel himself. In Westeros, the internal myth of the oath of noble service is that it's a path of honour. It's ongoing afaik. But everything still played out mostly the same, but without the bastard allegations, Harwin still I believe he has the name strong because qyburn is an agent of the Hightowers. News and discussions relating to George R. Hence why he beats up Harwin and kills Joffrey Lonmouth in the tourney. War seems a fine adventure, the greatest most of them will ever know. 889K subscribers in the asoiaf community. Criston Cole. And this is a man who performs Mengele-esque experiments on the living (The Citadel opens the bodies of the dead, Qyburn opens the bodies of the living) Go to asoiaf r/asoiaf News and discussions relating to George R. I would like to know what that moment or circumstances that earned him specific name. We know from Arya that Harwin, Robb, and Jon (those three at least), were all taught how to joust at Winterfell as she remembers watching them. Is it because Laena & Daemon were married? In F&B, we know just as much about Daemon’s relationship with Laena as we do Rhaenyra’s relationship with Harwin. "The Hand's daughter. With that in mind for Harwin to notable for being one of the largest and strongest men in the seven kingdoms he must be I hope that Harwin Strong is a nice guy in hotd (Spoilers Extended) I just like the idea that The guy named breakbones would be a kind and loving man. Pretty sure the Velaryons knew all along. This seems strange considering we have many characters in the current timeline that are significantly older (Aemon, Walder Frey Brothers march with brothers, sons with fathers, friends with friends. /r/PureASOIAFArt is a subreddit devoted to artistic depictions specifically from the book series A Song of Ice and Fire and associated written works by George R. I know he insisted for her to marry Laenor Velaryon to improve the relations Alyn and Harwin fared less well; Harwin was unhorsed in his first tilt by Ser Meryn of the Kingsguard, while Alyn fell to Ser Balon Swann. The seed is Strong as the saying goes. He dreamt an old dream, of three knights in white cloaks, and a tower long fallen, and Lyanna in her bed of blood. What if Larys and Harwin are working with some faction and are hiding their House in Essos. I'm not sure how this flew over my head but I just noticed that Harwin knelt before Arya in the same (or close enough) place that Torrhen Stark knelt for Aegon I. ”. R. In this story Harwin doesn't die in the Harrenhal fire and, after a lot of stuff including Laenor's fake death, they marry. It does not matter that Valyrian-looking parents in question may have non-Valyrian heritage - like Aerys and Rhaella. There’s two theories regarding this character I’ve heard, and they both have massive implications for his character and the story as a whole. R. Honestly, this seems like a cope. Tasked by Ser Tyland Lannister, the Hand of the King, with reclaiming the castle, Ser Regis Groves of the Kingsguard and Ser Damon Darry marched to Harrenhal with a hundred men. because she felt entitled to do whatever she wanted rather than her duty to her house and the realm. There is no way that Rhaenyra would choose Harwin over Daemon. Linkao3 (42008109) Twin Flames Dancing by cordeliacordate. ASOIAF genetics operate on certain rules. Her and Daemon are both fluent in it, but Jace is struggling with basic vocabulary even as an adult. Rule 1. Harwin was working in Kings Landing as a member of the Kings Guard. This series might qualify. Harwin just seemed like a genuine dude who loved Rhaenyra and their children. Yeah, Harwin is clearly not the better fighter, and it is a shame they removed the "Broken Bones" scene. Every man in ASOIAF with an aristocratic background would be educated in arms and command. Rhaenyra gave her favor to Harwin Strong, on the day of her wedding, similar to what Rhaegar did with Lyanna (bypassing his wife). Brandon Stark was born in the year 262 and died in 282. Even by the time of the main series with Varys, I don't think "Master of Whispers is an official position, but more of a courtesy title. “Arya Stark, of Winterfell". In the book, the three tourneys show Cole defeating Daemon, Joffrey and Harwin. In the same year, both Laenor is killed and Harwin burns to death (Lyonel dies anyway, as a result of being in the wrong place at the wrong time). EXTENDED. To reach the North unnoticed, they pass trough the Neck and Greywater Watch, where she is escorted by crannogmen, to avoid passing trough Moat Cailin. one significant difference is that joffrey, aegon and viserys are younger than they News and discussions relating to George R. Option 1 - Rhaenyra and Criston Cole both genuinely develop feelings for each other after he becomes her personal shield. It seems that the Strongs and the Hightowers at the end of the Dance could be working together and maybe House Strong still plays a larger part in asoiaf as a whole. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based short stories, "Game of Thrones" and "House of the Dragon" TV series, and all things ASOIAF - but with particular emphasis on the written series. In an imagined chivalric court - the kind of which Criston Cole may have dreamed - honour and glory would not just belong to the throne. In the dream his friends rode with him, as they had in life. Lady Stoneheart represents unchecked revenge. Martin. C, Daemon just benefits from it too much. Aside from the fact we never get a good physical description of Rhaenyra's mother (Aemma Arryn) or Harwin Strong suggests that anti-Rhaenyra folks don't want to point to others in the "Strong" boys' family trees who might have had brown hair and pug noses. In the book, they're Harwin's, and it's a pretty damn big deal that they all look like him. What does the Lord of Light want with Lady Stoneheart? (Spoilers Extended) EXTENDED. He’s the best fighter of his day, a man who used his martial abilities allowed him to rise to unthinkable heights for someone of his station and the show reduces him to a petty caricature. The way people try to paint someone wanting to have control over who they have sex with is bizzare. After she is forced into an engagement with Laenor - and perhaps even after she learns that Laenor already himself has another lover - she tries to seduce Criston and give him her maidenhead. So Rhaenyra sleeps with Harwin to make Criston jealous and drive him back to her, but he gets extremely angry and swears revenge. 911K subscribers in the HouseOfTheDragon community. TLDR: Ser Criston will confess to Alicent about his affair with Rhae based on guilt. Lady Stoneheart was brought to life by Beric Dondarrion, who then passed himself. We’re thirsty for a romance that’s not extremely f**ked up via GoT standards — and I’m not just referring to Targcest. The King should have had his head lopped right off after he killed Joffrey and shoved Laenor. ASOIAF is rightfully known for being a far darker, more cynical and bleaker than most fantasy book series and universes with all the political manipulations, the betrayals, the suffering that many have to endure, a good number of particulary nasty and horrifying characters and cultures and the many deaths that the plot sees happening. Ser Harold Westerling and his future in HotD (Spoilers extended) One of the less discussed changes in HotD is the role of Harold Westerling, the Lord Commander of the kingsguard. He was succeeded by Criston Cole who played a pivotal role as the Lord The knight was Ned. Jon also mentions that Robb is a better lance than him. “Is an analyst of ‘A Song of Ice And Fire’ a parasite?” “More or less,” Brienne answered. The time Rhaenyra is married to Harwin, I expect an Aegon-Laena wedding or a Laenor-Helaena wedding. Everything attributed to him up until the poisoning of Aegon II is consistent with that, and said The casting of the Sea Snake, Corlys Velaryon (spoilers extended) EXTENDED. And then she doesn't seem to have bothered teaching Jace or Luke any Valyrian. He 100% killed an innocent woman though. “A Targaryen alone in the world is a terrible thing. Him and Rhaenyra had a huge fall out before any children were conceived. But he’s just let off with zero consequences. . In the book this dude is shot to death with just three arrows. NOTE: My apologies for the wall of text. So Rhaenyra's chances to succeed are even less. Larys Strong’s Agenda [spoiler main] MAIN. I don’t have the quote verbatim, but Thoros describes his resurrections of Beric to not be a power of his own, but to be a power of the Lord of Light, using only Thoros as a vessel. In 132 AC during the regency of Aegon III, a number of broken men and predatory outlaws began to gather at Harrenhal under the rule of a sorcerous witch queen. This subreddit focuses only on the written works and does not allow content from the popular HBO television adaptations. His “victory” against Daemon is supposed to be decisive as he defeats Criston and Larys both have schemes that line up pretty effectively to remove Harwin and Lyonel. When Daemon took Harrenhal early in the Dance, she remained there. He is a formidable fighter, and I think the show suffers some by glossing over that. A sandpiper and a sea eagle both have wings, but they are not the same. This is one of the most intruiging events in asoiaf. (ASOS Sansa II) (ASOS Sansa II) When we meet Harwin again in ASOS , he's a "born again" R'hllorist, so to speak, and he very much wants the past to stay in the past and doesn't like when Catelyn is told The first death of the 120th year is Laena Velaryon. At first Joseth or HODOR would lead her, while Bran sat strapped to her back in the oversize saddle the Imp had drawn up for him, but for the past fortnight he had been riding her on his own, trotting her round and round, and growing bolder with every circuit. Alys Rivers seems to be a bastard. The fire killed the then hand of the king, Lord Lyonel Strong and his son and heir, the rumoured father of Rhaenyra's children, Harwin Strong. There’s this ASOIAF tabletop scenario packet that was based on an earlier version of the ASOIAF histories prior to the final version used for Fire & Blood, and Rhaenyra and Harwin did officially marry and her children were officially Strongs. The Tourney of Harrenhal took place in 281, so any child of Brandon’s would be born in 281 or 282. This series is completely removed from canon; 'elsewhere fics' with original characters. He planned for Lord Eddard to come west himself to deal with Gregor Clegane. ago. Martin's "A Song of Ice and Fire" novels, his Westeros-based… “Ser? My lady?” said Podrick. They've heard the songs and stories, so they go off with eager hearts, dreaming of the wonders they will see, of the wealth and glory they will win. Harwin heard that Ned and Ashara had hooked up at Harrenhal before the war. She's going to be a lesson for Arya, given that both Lady Stoneheart and Nymeria are in the same region of the Seven Kingdoms. The fight between Harwin and Cole removes Harwin from court. In Fire & Blood he died in 112 AC, 2 years before Rhaenyras first born son Jace was born. 8. The tour actively took her away from him. Jory is also a talented enough jouster, as shown by how he does in the Hand's Tourney. Otto having his network of spies kind of made him Master of whispers /r/darkwingsdankmemes is a meme subreddit devoted to the book series *A Song of Ice and Fire* and associated written works by George R. I made some assumptions with the earliest generations and in a couple other scenarios. I know Ser Harwin is said to be the Strongest Man in the Seven Kingdoms, but there had to be a specific moment that earned him the moniker "Breakbones". Harwin Strong was the better match for Rhaenyra, for a lot of reasons. ASOIAF. I have collected a few fixed/confirmed/probable errors in the series. Harwin Strong, known as Breakbones, was a knight from House Strong and the heir to Harrenhal. " Harwin went to one knee before her. Maybe she would let him see the kids once in a while but that would be it. Wedding to house Velaryon, a rich, powerful and dragonriding house, was the smartest move to strengthen her position. es wg yy ov rf em gp wm ez fx